On Wednesday, the Department of Planning and Natural Resources’ State Historic Preservation Committee held a lively discussion on various projects in the historic district of St. Thomas, focusing mainly on design reviews for commercial applicants, including iconic sites such as the Emancipation Garden and Fort Christian.
Regarding application HPC-38-2025, a design review for the Emancipation Garden, Educators Park, Fort Christian East and West Parks, and Vendors Plaza, the VI Office of Management and Budget’s representative, Somere A. Webber, presented an extensive project design to the board.
“They want to install a pergola in the upper section of Educators Park along with some steppingstone and a few concrete pads, to go down along with some date palms and other, I guess, landscaping efforts to this area,” said Webber.
Installation of irrigation lines, signage with QR codes for statue busts, and a transformer in Educators Park were also discussed. Moreover, Weber presented aspects such as the installation of Bermuda grass and informational plaques near Fort Christian, among other improvement efforts.
Correspondingly, after his presentation, acting board chair Enrique Rodriguez highlighted to the board his disapproval of the “I Love STT” sign in the Vendor’s Plaza location. He spoke about efforts to move it, inquiring with Weber to aid in its relocation.
“The background is just, it’s not a great photo op, and I’m so happy to see that sign moved to the Waterfront side of the water,” Rodriguez said.
However, as a result of the extensive redesign project presented by Webber, the committee voted to continue the application after conducting a more detailed review during an on-site meeting and walk-through.
Additionally, the board reviewed application HPC-48-2025 for the design of a Danish West Indian-themed retail plaza in Cardow and Post Office Alley in Kongens Quarter and approved the matter. Applicant Christina Lee Williams said she wants to create an artisan space for people to showcase their work.
“What we’re seeing right now downtown is just stores so to speak,” said Williams. “The plaza will serve as a gathering speed that enhances the downtown experience for both residents and visitors, because currently when a lot of tourists come to downtown, they ask for recommendations on where they can go for authentic food or certain experiences, and that’s that’s very limited downtown.”
According to Williams, the plaza will feature “gingerbread” style booths with historic features. The board appeared to be delighted by the idea. The application was approved in concept and the application will be continued for design development.
Furthermore, Williams presented application HPC-46-2025 for the use of blue paint colors with white and black trim details at Bjerge Gade 9A, Kongens Quarter. The board approved the application.
The Application HPC-30-2025 for the Garden Bar and Restaurant at Dronningens Gade 58A, Kongens Quarter, was continued for further exterior design development. It appeared that the board disapproved of the white, boxed design concept, with large signage presented by applicant Sherwin Rey.
“What you’re presenting to us is a beautiful space design for Redhook, but it’s completely out of place for the downtown historic district,“ said Rodriguez, who urged Rey and his team to coordinate with the Historic Preservation Committee to remain within compliance.
“Our concerns are the exterior,” added board member William Newbold.
Another board member, Kurt Marsh, spoke about the imitated arched doorways and hanging greenery that Rey said was placed to emulate a spout.
“I want to encourage you to take a step back a bit because you’re sterilizing the area a bit,” said Marsh
The committee voted to continue the matter at a later date.
The board approved application HPC-47-2025 for the design review of a wood trellis, a new business sign, a yellow alleyway paint color, and a menu board at the Veranda Escape Bar and Restaurant located at Dronningens Gade 16. Applicant Damni Ogando inquired with the board about the option to install an artificial grass lawn but was denied. The committee instead suggested that Ogando place grass in the crevices of the concrete tiles, rather than covering the entire floor.
Furthermore, the Port Authority’s application HPC-35-2025 was approved for revised elevations and a roof design at the Cruz Bay Fish Market. The applicant was also approved to paint the new building in the same color scheme as the St. John ferry terminal.
To note, applicants for HPC-42-2025 at Gamle Gade 14B, Kronprindsens Quarter, did not attend the meeting. Committee members William Newbold, Enrique Rodriguez, Mark Wiechnik, and Kurt G. Marsh were present.
St. Croix Source
Local news

